1437 GRAY HILL Road, New Columbia, PA 17856 (MLS# 20-100316)

$435,000
1437 GRAY HILL Road
New Columbia, PA 17856
MLS# 20-100316
Status: Closed
3 beds  |  3 baths  |  1734 sqft
front of house
  1 / 62  
front of house house view house view back of house side of house back deck Front door porch view Porch with Catio Front door to living area living room entryway living room wood burning stove with unique mantle ornate wood burning stove dining area dining into living kitchen Kitchen kitchen kitchen kitchen laundry room sunroom sunroom half bath half bath First floor Primary into ensuite bathroom first floor full bath first floor full bathroom Upstairs bedroom 2 Upstairs bedroom 2 jack and jill bathroom clawfoot tub in bedroom 3 upstairs bedroom 3 basement recreation room basement recreation room reflection dock on pond potting shed pond dock on pond swing Accessory Unit living area of studio unit living area studio unit kitchen of studio unit kitchen of studio unit bedroom of studio unit bathroom of studio unit two car garage relaxing pond cabin 1 cabin 1 cabin 1 interior White deer creek fishing dock Cabin 2 (Camp David) porch of cabin Interior Cabin (Camp David) Interior Cabin (Camp David) Cabin 3 (cottage) survey

Property Description
Welcome to a rare gem nestled in the heart of central Pennsylvania near an historic covered bridge —12 private, wooded acres where White Deer Creek winds gracefully through your backyard, offering the soothing sound of flowing water and endless opportunities for fly fishing, cooling off, or quiet reflection. The property features a sweet 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home filled with charm. Includes a separate residential unit—perfect for rental income, guest accommodations, or multigenerational living. Scattered across the grounds, you'll also find three rustic camping cabins ideal for creative retreats or camps. A tranquil pond invites peaceful mornings by the water, while the surrounding woods offer privacy, inspiration, and room to roam. Call Nicole today for your private tour. 917.808.6367

Details
Maps
Documents
Contract Information
Current Price: $435,000
Book Section: Residential
Status: Closed
Begin Date: 2025-05-17
Sold Price: $435,000
Assessed Valuation: 222200
General Property Description
Style: Cape Cod
Total SqFt.: 1734
SqFt. B: 1008
SqFt. 1: 1008
SqFt. 2: 726
Apx Above Grade Finished SqFt: 1734
Year Built: 2004
Actual/Est YearBuilt: Actual
Realtor.COM Type: Residential - Single Family
Lot Size: 12.12
Lot Acres: 12.12
Total Bedrooms: 3
Baths - Total Full: 1
Baths - Total 3/4: 1
Baths - Total Half: 1
Baths - Total: 3
Garage Stall: 2 Car
Garage Type: Detached
Remarks
Permanent Book Msg: A Nature-Lover's Retreat
Directions
Directions: From Rt 15 take New Columbia Rd. North. Turn Right on Gray Hill Road. Driveway in on the left before the covered bridge.
Details
House Color: Grey
Exclusions: Wthr vane, curtains
Parking Spaces: many
Sold Information
Under Contract Date: 2025-07-20
Sold Date: 2025-08-08
Sold Price: $435,000
Location Tax and Other Information
Area: New Columbia
House Number: 1437
Street Name: GRAY HILL
Street Suffix: Road
County: Union
State/Province: PA
Postal Code: 17856
Municipality: White Deer Twp
Zoning: Agricultural
Subdivision: 0-None
PIN Number: 014-054-123.30000
Property Features
Details: 1st Floor Laundry
Construction: Frame
Exterior Finish: Vinyl
Amenities: Pond; Stream; Studio; View
Kitchen Appliances: Dishwasher; Microwave Oven; Refrigerator; Stove/Range
Interior Features: Ceiling Fan; Dryer; Washer; Window Treatments; Wood Stove
Exterior Features: Porch; Shed
Green Energy Generation: Solar
Document: Deed; Tax Card; Aerial Map; Surveys
Supplements
White Deer Creek is a famous tributary of the West Branch of the Susquehanna River. It is known for its trout fly fishing frequently receiving top ratings for conditions from fly fishing forecasting sites. The home is an inviting three bedroom cottage. A unique mantle made of rough cut cherry tree trunk frames a wood stove for warm winter nights. The front porch invites you to sip ice tea on a hot summer day, with a special "catio" (patio for cats) for your fur babies to enjoy fresh air. The lovely landscaping enhances the enchanted nature of this property. The cabins peppered throughout the trees are works of art in themselves. With no electricity or running water they are perfect for writing, art making, or nature retreats. Reminiscent of the experimental art school, Black Mountain College, this property truly offers itself to the artist, philosopher and dendrophile. Summer berries grow abundantly along the pond's edge and catfish live below the surface. Whether you're seeking a secluded homestead, an investment opportunity, or a nature-inspired lifestyle, this unique property offers space to breathe and a setting that truly feels like home. The stewards of this land have lovingly enjoyed it for more than two decades and are now ready to find its next custodians. Contact Nicole for more information.
Listing Office: COLDWELL BANKER PENN ONE REAL ESTATE
Listing Agent: Nicole Will

Last Updated: August - 08 - 2025

DISCLAIMER NOTICE: The information above is provided exclusively for the use of Members of the Central Susquehanna Valley MLS ('CSVBR-MLS'). Buyers and all other individuals not members of the CSVBR-MLS ('all non-MLS members') are NOT AUTHORIZED TO UTILIZE THIS INFORMATION AND HAVE NO RIGHT TO RELY ON IT. All non-MLS members must independently verify all information important to them and agree to hold all members of the CSVBR-MLS harmless from all liability for the accuracy of this information if they fail to independently verify that information. Antitrust Compliance Notice. See Notice.

Search powered by FBS Products